Embody Fitness - Luxury Personal Training in the heart of London

Main Menu

  • [email protected]

To Squat or Not to Squat?

To squat or not to squat?

So when you come to do your personal training sessions at Embody, you have certain expectations as to what exercises your trainer will have you do. Today we look at one of our all-time favourites…

The squat – and let’s get things straight here, I’m talking about the full back squat with the bar sat on top of the shoulders/upper back – is one of the most controversial and written about exercises there is. I’ve changed my opinion of the squat over the years and have some very firm opinions on its use and applicabil-ity to populations and situations. Here’s my take on ‘The King of Lower Body Exercises’:

The squat is one of the most effective exercises for developing strength and power in the lower limb as well as developing muscle mass and definition, which is why it is common for personal trainers and strength and conditioning coaches to use it for developing strength and power in the lower limb as well as muscle mass and definition. There are not many muscles that are not involved, in some way, while squatting – especially when you take into consideration the trunk (I hate the term ‘core’) musculature that is having to stabilise the spine in order to prevent unwanted movements (incidentally – that’s the definition of stability in my book – the ability to prevent an unwanted movement). Add to this the massive beneficial hormonal effect that multi-ple sets of heavy squats will have by stimulating testosterone and growth hormone production.

So, if the squat is such a good exercise, why the controversy?

I don’t need to go back through the annuls of history to give you the exact time and place when it happened but someone once said that squatting so that your knees go more acute than 90 degrees is bad for the knee. Someone else once said that the knees should, under no circumstances, go over the toes.

I know this to be true because I was taught, and subsequently taught, the very same technique. It doesn’t matter who said it, or what their reason was – they were wrong! There was never any explanation why this technique was bad – just that it was really bad!

Actually, what has subsequently come to light is that not going beyond 90 degrees and not allowing your knees to go over the toes is inherently bad for the knees as you will not recruit the glutes to their full extent, nor will you fully recruit the vastus medialis muscle on the inside of the quadriceps.

As the stability of the knee relies on the strength of both the glutes and the quadriceps, surely their lack of strength would be a bad thing? Add to this the fact that the knee joint is capable of moving through a certain range – so why not go through that full range? I would never advise someone to do half a biceps curl ‘be-cause it’s bad for the elbow’ so why would I do the same for the knee? If nature intended it to stop halfway it would have changed the structure of the knee so that, mechanically, you would not be able to move it be-yond a certain range. I once read that countries whose populations spend a lot of time eating or hanging around in a deep squat position have a far lower incidence of orthopaedic knee surgeries than Western countries. Yet more reason to exercise through the full range of motion!

So, do I now programme the squat into all my programmes? Not exactly. Here is my thought process when deciding whether or not to use the squat.

1. Does the subject possess the mobility to perform a squat properly? I am talking here about whether they can maintain an upright spine with natural lumbar curve while the thighs pass parallel and the feet stay firmly on the floor without the heels moving inwards. The reality is that many people won’t be capable of perform-ing a decent looking squat so why, therefore, would I put 100+kg on their back and ask them to hope for the best. When I worked in a professional rugby environment I banned squats for all but 2 of the players as inju-ries kept occurring to the lower backs of some players following heavy squat sessions. Remember that the number 1 goal of a strength and conditioning coach is injury prevention – it doesn’t matter how good the player is if they are not on the pitch/court etc. The next time you are in the company of a toddler playing, watch how they pick things up – it will be with perfect squat form.

2. Is the risk reward ratio positive? By going heavy is the potential reward greater than the risk of injury from potentially poor technique/fatigue induced poor technique? If not then why bother? Again – see point 1. The same applies to all of our personal training clients – keep them healthy and they will be able to train consistently and reach their goals. Injure them and they will lose motivation. Someone with a strength dis-crepancy between legs would not benefit from squats as it reinforces the discrepancy and does nothing to correct it.

3. Is squatting specific to the achievement of goals/will it improve performance? This is a big one for me. From a sporting perspective, I cannot think of many sports (powerlifting, weightlifting and rowing aside) where both legs are used together at the same time. Most field/court based sports, as well as endurance sports, rely on single leg strength in order to run, jump, change direction, speed up and slow down.

So why not programme exercises that address single leg strength and the stability that is required to perform powerful single limb contractions?

Single leg strength

As you will have guessed, I don’t really use squats that much anymore, preferring instead to use split squats, front and rear foot elevated split squats, lunges, side step ups, front step ups, Russian step ups, triple jump-ers step ups and … Goblet squats! I love goblet squats because holding weight in front of the chest some-how allows people who are unable to perform regular squats, to perform great looking squats. It’s difficult to load too heavy (as your arms burn) and easier to reach the correct range of movement.

My lack of use of the squat has not been detrimental to any of the clients/athletes I’ve worked with – quite the opposite. We don’t see the same injuries to the hips/lower back region and I’d say that they were functionally stronger. Meaning that they were better able to do whatever it is they train to do!

At Embody all clients undergo a screening process with our Sports Injury and Rehabilitation specialist who will assess mobility/stability and help direct programme writing so that injuries can be avoided. This focus on form and functional movement means that we maximise our results by making sure we avoid injury as much as possible. Our screening process distinguishes us from this competition and keeps our discerning, London based clientele healthy from a musculoskeletal perspective and therefore better able to train consistently! As a famous American strength coach once said – “if you’re not assessing, you’re guessing”.

Article written by Chris Walton

Prev Getting the basics right – Sleep
Next Embody Beats Diabetes

You may also be interested in...

Personal Training a client at Embody Fitness

Fitness coach vs personal trainer: What is the difference?

These days, social media is flooded with so-called health and fitness experts, all confidently sharing their opinion on the best way to lose weight and get fit. So, if you’re…

VIEW POST
Personal Training Trainer London | Transformation of the Month: Chris April 30th, 2015

Transformation of the Month: Chris

“The thing I liked most about Embody is that everyone at the gym helped me with my goal. Whenever I was in the gym, even PTs who I didn’t work with were checking in on how I was doing. It felt like a real family.”

Online Training

Register your interest today to be the first to know when we bring back online training.

Privacy Policy

Book Your Free Consultation

Know when you want to come visit us? Use the button below to book a confirmed consultation date and time online, we also welcome you to use the form below and a member of our team will get in touch to confirm a time and date.

BOOK ONLINE CONSULTATION

Privacy Policy

Book Your Free Consultation

Know when you want to come visit us? Use the button below to book a confirmed consultation date and time online, we also welcome you to use the form below and a member of our team will get in touch to confirm a time and date.

BOOK ONLINE CONSULTATION

Privacy Policy

PRIVACY POLICY

  • All credit/debit cards details and personally identifiable information will NOT be stored, sold, shared, rented or leased to any third parties. 
  • The Website Policies and Terms & Conditions may be changed or updated occasionally to meet the requirements and standards. Therefore the Customers’ are encouraged to frequently visit these sections in order to be updated about the changes on the website. Modifications will be effective on the day they are posted.
  • Some of the advertisements you see on the Site are selected and delivered by third parties, such as ad networks, advertising agencies, advertisers, and audience segment providers. These third parties may collect information about you and your online activities, either on the Site or on other websites, through cookies, web beacons, and other technologies in an effort to understand your interests and deliver to you advertisements that are tailored to your interests. Please remember that we do not have access to, or control over, the information these third parties may collect. The information practices of these third parties are not covered by this privacy policy. 
  • This website is managed and owned by Embody Fitness LLC

ONLINE PAYMENT GATEWAY – TERMS AND CONDITIONS

Any dispute or claim arising out of or in connection with this website shall be governed and construed in accordance with the laws of the United Kingdom.

The United Kingdom is our country of domicile.

Minors under the age of 18 shall are prohibited to register as a User of this website and are not allowed to transact or use the website.

If you make a payment for our products or services on our website, the details you are asked to submit will be provided directly to our payment provider via a secured connection.

The cardholder must retain a copy of transaction records and Merchant policies and rules.

www.embodyfitness.co.uk will NOT deal or provide any services or products to any of OFAC (Office of Foreign Assets Control) sanctions countries in accordance with the law of UAE.

Multiple transactions may result in multiple postings to the cardholder’s monthly statement.

PRODUCTS/ SERVICES

See our pricing details here

METHOD OF PAYMENT

We accept payments online using Visa and MasterCard credit/debit cards in GBR.

REFUND POLICY

Refunds will be done only through the Original Mode of Payment.

ADDRESS & CONTACT INFORMATION

Embody Fitness

1st Floor, 1 Bartholomew Lane,
London EC2N 2AX

[email protected]

0207 628 2827

Embody Fitness Terms and Conditions

FITNESS AND HEALTH

The Client is responsible for making sure he/she is in good physical condition at each visit and that the Client knows of no medical or other condition why the Client is not capable of exercising at the facility. Neither Embody Fitness staff nor any staff members or representatives are medically trained and are therefore not qualified to assess whether the Client is in good physical condition and/or that the Client can engage in any exercise without detriment to the Client’s health, safety, comfort or physical condition. Embody Fitness and the Personal Trainer/Therapist reserves the right to refuse access to any client if they consider that the health of the individual concerned may be endangered by the use of the facilities. Clients shall not use Embody Fitness’s facilities nor engage with a Personal Trainer/Therapist if they are suffering from any medical conditions.

CANCELLATION POLICY

Any cancellations made within 24 hours of a scheduled session shall be charged at the full rate.

PERSONAL BELONGINGS

Personal belongings brought into the Facilities shall at all times remain at the Client’s risk including any personal belongings stored in lockers provided by Embody Fitness. The Client accepts and agrees that neither Embody Fitness nor its employees or representatives shall be liable for any loss, damage or theft of any property belonging to, or brought onto or left outside any Embody Fitness premises by the Client or any guest of the Client.

GENERAL

Intellectual Property: The Client agrees to having their photographs taken whilst at Embody Fitness facilities. Any data, information and copyright in any photographic or other images taken by Embody Fitness or on its behalf of the Client or relating to the Client whilst training in the Facilities shall belong to Embody Fitness absolutely and can be used for promotion, marketing and commercial exploitation of the Facilities in such form as Embody Fitness shall require from time to time. The Client agrees to having their photograph taken.

PAYMENTS

Payment for programmes and membership shall be made in full upon purchase and prior to the commencement of any programme. Any monthly payments for programmes or personal training blocks must be provided by authorised advanced credit card payment or post-dated cheques. Any failed or rejected payments shall incur an administrative fee of AED500 and services shall be suspended until payment has been made.

NO RIGHT TO CANCEL

Payments for programmes and blocks of sessions are non-refundable and cannot be cancelled. If a client chooses to cancel this agreement, they will remain liable to pay the balance of any unpaid instalments at the date of cancellation. No refunds will be provided for any unused sessions.


VALIDITY OF SERVICES

Each programme or training block is valid for up to 6 months from the date of this Agreement. Any unused sessions at that point shall be forfeited and there is no right of refund.

FREE COMPREHENSIVE
QUICK-START NUTRITION GUIDE

Start your body transformation today, download
your free expert nutrition guide.

Privacy Policy